Vitamin D: Are You D-Pleted?

Learn why the 'sunshine vitamin' is so important to your health.

Photo Illustration by Michael Northrup

Update Aug. 26, 2010: In a recent study published in Genome Research, a team of British and Canadian scientists found that the “sunshine vitamin,” vitamin D, interacts with and may even regulate genes related to colorectal cancer, type 1 diabetes and other diseases. More research is needed, but this study lends further evidence to the importance of getting enough vitamin D.

 

Unless you live in the tropics, you probably need more D, a vitamin produced in the skin by ultraviolet (UV) rays from sunlight. Grey skies, weak winter sun, sunscreen use and an indoor lifestyle mean that most of us are lacking in this essential vitamin.

“Most blood tests we order for vitamin D show that levels are low or moderately low,” says Jessica Strasburg, MD, a family practitioner at Cleveland Clinic Solon Family Health Center. “Many adults are at risk for vitamin D deficiency, since the ability to produce and utilize the vitamin decreases with age.” 

A key role in your health

Too little vitamin D may result in serious health problems. “Vitamin D is important to bone health. It is vital for normal calcium absorption and critical in treating osteoporosis. In children, lack of vitamin D causes rickets,” says Bruce Long, MD, a Cleveland Clinic rheumatologist with a special interest in the vitamin. 

Vitamin D is also thought to play a role in preventing cancer, heart attacks, strokes and diabetes, and may help preserve thinking and memory. The vitamin also appears to prevent hypertension during pregnancy, calm the pain of arthritis, and increase muscle strength and coordination. It may even help prevent and treat multiple sclerosis.

How to get your D

Fifteen minutes of afternoon summer sun daily on unprotected arms and legs will give you what you need. “You need strong, direct sunlight,” says Dr. Strasburg. So most of us should leave off the sunscreen for 15 minutes — and then apply it to prevent skin cancer. 

However, if you are at risk for skin cancer or have a history of skin cancer, you’ll need alternative sources of vitamin D. You can get some vitamin D by taking multivitamins or calcium supplements with D. The vitamin is found in fatty fish, egg yolks and beef liver, and is added to yogurt and other calcium-fortified products. These include milk, cereal, bread and some brands of orange juice.

Most of us need supplementation

Even with these measures it’s hard to ingest enough vitamin D to meet the recommended daily allowance, which will soon increase to 800 international units per day. “That’s why most doctors in northern Ohio recommend vitamin D supplements,” says Dr. Strasburg.

A simple blood test will let you know if your vitamin D levels are normal. If your levels are low, your doctor will prescribe vitamin D and recheck levels in about three months. If they are still low, your dose will be increased; if they’re too high, it will be lowered.

1,000-5,000 units a day typical

“Generally, our patients take 1,000 to 5,000 units of vitamin D3 (available over the counter in 400, 800, 1,000 and 2,000 units) once a day. Some who require high doses may choose to take 50,000 units of vitamin D2 (a prescription drug) once or twice a week,” says Dr. Long. “D2 and D3 are both effective, but those bothered by taking too many capsules often choose vitamin D2.”

Having bariatric surgery or untreated celiac disease usually means you need higher doses of D because less of the vitamin is reabsorbed through the digestive tract. Also, with aging, we make less vitamin D3 in our skin and may need higher doses.

Once vitamin D levels are normal, doses are adjusted to avoid potential toxicity.  “One study found toxic levels of vitamin D among individuals taking 40,000 units daily for five months. However, no toxicity was found among those taking 10,000 units daily for five months, and taking 1,000 units daily is safe,” says Dr. Long.

 

Published December 2009


Sign up for Be Well eNews, our free eNewsletter. Stay connected.

Comments

I started taking 50,000

I started taking 50,000 units/week because my level was 9. I had an immediate reaction (loss of appetite, extreme thirst, hoarseness) and subsequent exacerbated food allergies. After 8 weeks, I switched to 2,000 units/day and at 3 months, my level was above 40 but I felt horrible. I went down to 1,000/day and started feeling better, so stopped all supplements and of course my level is low again. I've tested positive for Hashimoto's (AntiTPO & Tg Ab), ANA & RF and feel like I'm in limbo and not able to get any advice on what to do. My TSH is borderline, so PCP won't treat. I know it has been suggested that low vitamin D may be a protective mechanism in some autoimmine diseases and I can't help but wonder if my reaction falls in that area. I have an appt with a Rheumatologist soon, so any thoughts or advice on what to ask, tests, etc. would be appreciated.

6 months ago my Vitamin D

6 months ago my Vitamin D level was 26. I took Rx D, 50,000 IU for 13 weeks, then every other week since (3 months) In addition, I was told to continue the daily 1600 IU D3, (which I did, except for the past 6 weeks.) I just was retested, & my level of D has dropped to 22! Now Dr. wants me to take the 50,000 D2 Rx twice a week & retest in 4 months.

My question is: If the above doesn't raise me into normal levels (as I understand D2 isn't always as well absorbed as D3) what dose of D3 should I discuss taking with my Dr? I'd like to have an idea in advance, as I won't be seeing her after the next test - she just mails Rx & notes to me, so there's never a chance for a followup discussion. Thank you.

D Levels

I had my Vit D checked and it was 22. I was put on D2 for 3 months one pill a week and then told to take 2000 a day after this. Does this sound right. I am taking Celexa and was taking Ativan. Can this effect D levels?

Normal levels of 25 OH

Normal levels of 25 OH Vitamin D are 30-80 ng/ml. When levels are low, supplementation is wise. Vitamin D is very important for bones, muscles, and for the immune system, and can also have an impact on the nervous system and cardiovascular system. A weekly dose of Vitamin D2 50,000 IU is often recommended, commonly followed by a daily dose of Vitamin D3 2000 IU .  What your doctor prescribed seems very reasonable. Blood levels of Vitamin D25 OH may be re-checked after you have been on Vitamin D supplements to see if the level is right for you.  I am not aware of Celexa or Ativan affecting Vitamin D levels, but some seizure medications may lower vitamin D levels; if you have further questions, check with your doctor. — Bruce Long, MD

Vitamin D and low fat diet

I am 69 years old with five 20 year old heart by passes. I am eat a 11% fat plant based diet. Will a daily 2000 IU vitamin D supplement assimilate. I also take a calcium/magnesium supplement. I am not using any medication.

Thank you for your comments.

I recommend at least baby

I recommend at least a baby aspirin a day and ideally, your LDL should be less than 70 and your non-HDL (total cholesterol minus HDL) should be less than 100. Moreover, your blood pressure should be less than 140/90 but ideally less than 130/80. — Leslie Cho, MD

Always consult with your

Always consult with your doctor before taking any supplements or medication. I would recommend a dose of vitamin D3 2000 IU daily. However, I would check blood levels (Vitamin D25 OH) after three months. A goal of at least 40 ng/ml is reasonable. Normal level is 31-80 in most labs. — Raul Seballos, MD

I am 32 years old and my

I am 32 years old and my vitamin d levels were basically non existent. The doctor told me the lab tests they conducted only read as low as < 7 and that is where mine registered at. I take 2,000 IU daily and 50,000 IU twice a week. How long should it take to correct ? And is there certain type of doctor i should be going to for this other then just a general physician ?

Typically, one can have

Typically, one can have vitamin D levels rechecked every two to three months to make sure the level increases appropriately. No special doctor is needed for a vitamin D deficiency at this point. 

 — Jessica Strasburg, MD
Family Medicine/Women's Health

Vit D levels

What levels should a woman at 69 be looking for before adding vitamin d to diet? Mine is 22. How do I know if I am depleted?

The "normal range" is in

The "normal range" is in debate, but in general 30-50 is considered "normal" or ideal. A level of 22 is slightly low. Depending on other medical problems and if you have osteoporosis, your physician may want to give a higher dose initially. For most fairly healthy patients, 2000 IU of vitamin D3, over the counter, once a day is sufficient. You should discuss this with your physician, of course. — Jessica Strasburg, MD

VIT D

Having had gastric bypass 8 yrs ago, I am low in Vit D, last
yr I was given 50,000 units? I took it for 8 weeks--pure hell
is all I can say. I had severe headahes plus other aches.
What caused this is what has me wondering, could I have
been taking way tooo much?? Thanks

50,000 units of Vitamin D2 is

50,000 units of Vitamin D2 is a common dose and often people need that much. Headaches are not common with Vitamin D, but you may want to try Vit D 3 2000 units on a daily basis. — Bruce Long, MD

Therapeutic doses of vitamin

Therapeutic doses of vitamin D such as the dose you were consuming should be monitored by blood work levels by the physician prescribing the vitamin. Headaches, bone pain, nausea, constipation and weakness are a few signs of vitamin D toxicity. Levels should be rechecked to verify you are in a therapeutic range (normal).

In addition, it would be prudent to have your parathyroid hormone PTH intact checked annually after gastric bypass. This is an indicator of how hard your parathyroid gland is working to keep calcium in your bones. — Laura Smolenak, RN, Bariatric & Metabolic Institute

Vit D and Sarcoidosis

What is your position on Vit D and sarcoidosis and other TH1 immune pathway difficulties AKA who don't' process D well and get sick from it?

It is well-established that

It is well-established that between 2 and 20% of patients with sarcoidosis metabolize Vitamin D abnormally. This may lead to excessive production of the active form of Vitamin D, dihydroxy-Vitamin D, even when there is an overall deficiency of dietary Vitamin D. As a result, some patients develop high calcium levels in the blood or even kidney stones. For these patients, it is important to talk with your doctor about the status of Vitamin D levels, risks of prolonged sunlight exposure, and bone health. However, the majority of patients with sarcoidosis, as well as other inflammatory diseases, do not experience negative effects from sunlight or ingestion of Vitamin D.

Vitamin D also plays a number of roles in modulating the immune system. Some individuals have postulated that excess Vitamin D may lead to worsened inflammation in sarcoidosis and other diseases. However, there are also scientific reasons to suggest that Vitamin D in many situations actually turns down inflammation. The scientific literature on this point is very far from settled, so one cannot be dogmatic about the issue. I generally ask patients with sarcoidosis to pay attention to their body's response to sun exposure, and to take common-sense precautions regarding excessive exposure, similar to the general population.

— Daniel Culver, DO

Vitamin D

In your recent article on Vitamin D, it was said that there is D2 and D3. How does this make a difference? Also, what is a normal level of Vit. D. Thanks for the info.

Two forms are important in

Two forms are important in humans: ergocalciferol (vitamin D2) and cholecalciferol (vitamin D3). Vitamin D2 is synthesized by plants. Vitamin D3 is synthesized by humans in the skin when it is exposed to ultraviolet-B (UVB) rays from sunlight. Foods may be fortified with vitamin D2 or D3

Vitamin D2 is longer acting and needs to be taken only 1-2 times a week. Vitamin D3 is shorter acting and needs to be taken daily.

Most think D3 is more potent, but for very low levels we'll have the patient take the high dose of D2 for a few months and maintain on the D3 after levels become therapeutic. — Jessica Strasburg, MD

Cleveland Clinic © 1995-2011. All Rights Reserved.  9500 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio 44195 | 216.444.2200 | 800.223.2273 | TTY 216.444.0261